The other night, at The Pogues show, I got talking to some guys in the audience, and they started talking about Jimmy Buffett. What his concerts were like, the atmosphere, the lifestyle, and so on. You know it: the Hawaiian shirts, the laid-back vibe, the big outdoor shows and everyone drinking margaritas. It's never been my scene, but hey, a lot of people like it, so that's fine.
But then I got thinking: isn't everyone at this Pogues show pretty much doing the same thing? We're singing along to a batch of well-worn favorites, drinking our specialty drinks (Guinness or whiskey), and more or less proclaiming to be part of some sort of special subgroup in America: Pogues Nation, or Shaneheads. The pseudo-descendants of the Irish diaspora.
And tomorrow is our big day, the day the tricolor gets pulled out and the green clothes and the mumblings of "Danny Boy" or "The Wild Rover" filter through the air.
And it's not even my day, or my group, so to speak. There might be some Irish on my dad's side of the family, but beats me if I know how much. I'm mostly Scottish and German and some English, so my predilection towards all things Celtic is pretty much a sham.

So what's the big deal with the Irish? We could all be victims of marketing. That's what Pete McCarthy struggled with in his book
McCarthy's Bar. We could be swilling the Guinness at the Authentic Irish Pubs that dot the suburban landscape because that's been the latest craze, where before that it was Hawaiian tiki lounges in the 50s and 60s.
But can you adopt a lifestyle that isn't your own by rights of ancestry? Is being "Irish" in America no different than being a Parrothead? I think the millions of true Irish-Americans across the country would disagree. Those with actual families back in West Cork or Dublin or Kinsale. I wonder if they get a little cheesed off at the appropriation of a genuine ethic background, especially on St. Patrick's Day, when "everyone's a little bit Irish."
I suppose St. Patrick's Day, and the Irish experience in America, has become the shorthand version of everyone's immigrant past: poor families escape starvation and tyrannical rule to come to America, struggle, and eventually make good. Plus it involves drinking, which helps. And everyone likes a good protest song sing-a-long. So we take our own ancestral immigrant background and celebrate it on Paddy's Day.

I've been traveling to Ireland for several years now, to get myself past my original concepts of what "Irish" is and isn't. It certainly isn't corned beef and cabbage; it isn't craggy-faced old men singing "Danny Boy"; and it isn't a land made entirely of green fields and little white thatched-roof cottages.
All of that stuff is there, of course, for those that come over and want the "authentic" Irish experience. (Except the corned beef and cabbage; I've never once seen that on a menu in Ireland. I'm guessing that's a New York-Irish immigrant thing.)
For a while Ireland was, for me, the rowdy music of The Pogues; the poems of Yeats; and the Guinness in the pubs. Three things I took to immediately. But they don't exactly tell the entire story. That's why I keep going over there. I want to keep pushing past the familiar, well-trotted-out bits of what supposedly makes Ireland
Ireland, and understand the place on a deeper level.
After six years of travel over there, I feel like I've just barely begun to understand the place. The stuff I used to know, like the songs and the legends and the troubled history, it's all there, and it's definitely a part of Ireland. But that's like saying that the U.S. is nothing but bluegrass and John Henry and robber barons.
It still intrigues me endlessly. The more I know, the more I want to know. And I know I'm not alone in that sentiment, considering the massive amount of attention paid to Ireland and Irish culture here in America. But if my fascination were merely a Parrothead-style appreciation for whiskey and The Chieftains, that wouldn't do the place and the people proper justice.
It's more than that. What that is, I don't quite know, but I love this long, slow process of finding out.
Happy Paddy's Day, everyone.