
I'm letting the Fanboys take over the blog this week, so expect a lot of geek-talk and inside references about Star Wars. The great monster from my childhood is returning for one final installment, and it seems to be rekindling my love for Lucas and lightsabers.
This was submitted by my buddy Hal, in response to my last post. Hal and I (and MC who often appears in the comments) spent our entire childhoods obsessing over anything
Star Wars, and we knew exactly what Kevin Smith meant when he said that Star Wars was our Vietnam. (A glib statement, yes, but we didn't have much else going on in the late-70s and early 80s. Do you think the Carter administration was going to be the most memorable event from our early childhood? Hell no! It was Vader making all those guys choke to death just by flicking out two robotic fingers.)
Anyway, here's the Hal 9000's Best/Worst list for the
Star Wars films.
Best Moment in the original Star Wars:(Tie) 1. The uncomfortable dinner conversation over blue milk and old
ghosts. I agree that Lucas made a bunch of this shit up on the fly, but
that conversation is proof that not everything was made up on the fly.
2. The opening crawl. From the beginning of the film, the written setup,
and the spacecraft lumbering overhead, you knew there was something really
cool about to take place.
Worst moment in Star Wars:I can't think of one, so Tosche Station will have to do.
Best Moment in The Empire Strikes Back:(Tie) As you know, I'm big on the moment of revelation, so it's little
wonder the (paternal) climax of the film is my favorite moment. And it
gives the film real legitimacy, in that, to date, it is the only film in the
series where the climactic moment is a plot point/point of character
development instead of a special effect.
Also, I love the moment when the soldiers in the trench whip out the
binoculars, see the AT-ATs and realize just how screwed they are.
Worst Moment, ESB:Again, hard to pick one, but I'm going to go with the space slug. Nothing
can make me suspend disbelief to that degree.
Best Moment in Jedi:The fleet drops out of hyperspace, both because of Lando's moment of
revelation regarding the Death Star's defensive shields and because the
battle was seriously joined. Latter day digital space battles are cool, but
somewhere down deep, I long for miniatures, models and old school special
effects.
Worst Moment in Jedi:The battle above Endor kicked ass, but the battle on the surface sucked
bantha dick. I agree, Ewoks in and of themselves are lame, but I'm going to
have to go with the surface battle on this one. Chaotic and unintelligible,
and it had the added lameness of the tired and overused "close-to-nature
beats science and technology" theme that's been used in everything from
Rocky IV to the Vietnam War. And it was the worst forest battle put to
film since "Battle for the Planet of the Apes."
Best moment in Phantom Menace:There was one? I suppose Darth Maul vs. the Jedi would count, but that's
it.
Worst moment, TPM:Jar Jar Binks, podracing, Warwick Davis...where to start? I'll just leave
it at the fact that it was one huge turd, beginning to end.
Seriously, I'd rather have kidney stone surgury than watch this film again.
At least there, I got fentanyl.
(And as an aside, this started the end of midnight shows for me. I swore
Return of the King was it, but I feel the force, and now I'm swearing -
absolutely for the last time - Sith is my absolute last midnight show. I've
been burned once too often, and I'd rather have the sleep.)
Best moment in Attack of the Clones:One of so very few in the prequels, I love the moment when the battle droids
pour into the arena to face a charging line of Jedi Knights with lightsabers
drawn. Its a scene I had imagined in my own mind, and hoped for, for years.
Worst moment:"...and sand...it gets everywhere..."
George, you're a rich old ba$tard: hire a script doctor, or even better, a
co-writer. Leigh Brackett could still write better than you, and she's been
dead 20 plus years.
And your review didn't give props to Clone Wars, which is better than the
first two prequels combined:
Best moment, Clone wars:Clone soldiers take down that gun on Muunilist. Finally, 3 minutes where
stormtroopers act like a real fucking army unit.
Worst moment, Clone Wars:Hard to pick one, but I'll go with C-3PO's comic relief on Illum. I've
heard there's little in the way of comic relief in Sith, and I hope it stays
that way.
I also hope I get the satisfaction of seeing Jar Jar Binks get his
intestines spilled out, Taun Taun-style. Only time will tell.
And George doesn't get any more money out of me until I get the first three
in their original formats on DVD. You can enhance the color and the sound
all you want, George, but no more money from me until Obi-Wan no longer
lives at Xanadu, Greedo doesn't shoot first, you leave the Jabba scene on
the cutting room floor, reinsert the wolfman, erase the dewbacks, leave the
wampa vague as hell, reinsert Clive Revill, erase that damn scream, return
it to "Bring my ship" instead of "Alert my Star Destroyer to prepare for my
arrival", get rid of the goddamn "musical" number in Jabba's palace, and put
Sebastian Shaw back in the ending.